Thread: Discuss the GBP/USD with a DailyFX Analyst

Originally Posted by lovelyforex

if still fight here..maybe lovelyforex surrender this forum and do it alone with my best friend from Florida Mr Tom he also great trader in longterm analysist and goods scalpers .

You gave me good idea
So, from now Iam quit from here.
I like some traders from here but I think here isnt
community for me

So. All the best.

p.s. lovely. If sometime you will like to trade with me, you know where to find me

bye

Originally Posted by BH-Eurofighter

You gave me good idea
So, from now Iam quit from here.
I like some traders from here but I think here isnt
community for me

So. All the best.

p.s. lovely. If sometime you will like to trade with me, you know where to find me

bye

This will be a big loss for this forum

I will be sorry to see you go, if you would please send me a PM and let me know where you will be

Thanks

Originally Posted by BH-Eurofighter

You gave me good idea
So, from now Iam quit from here.
I like some traders from here but I think here isnt
community for me

So. All the best.

p.s. lovely. If sometime you will like to trade with me, you know where to find me

bye

how i know you in where..now i in MARS ..will flying to the earth
sooner..can i meet u there? just joking for release your tension about that..

For moderator allw me speak in my language a moment

salam semua rakan2 trader.dalam forum ini ramai yang hebat2 dari sudut teknikal.jika konfius mana satau nak ikut lebih baik jgn trade.saya nasihatkan rakan2 semua gabungkan kesemua rekomen2 yg di beri menjadi satu iaitu satu arah then dengan konfiden dapat trade dengan aman dan buat profit yg hebat.saya pasti anda semua sudah ada idola masing2 kat sini.katakan si A kata naik si B kata turun si C kata naik dan si D kata naik so = ikut naik

jika kesmua kata satu trend/arah akan dapat buat profit melebihi 100 pips pasti..tapi jangan panik just relax.

Originally Posted by CodyB

This will be a big loss for this forum

I will be sorry to see you go, if you would please send me a PM and let me know where you will be

Thanks

here on this forum

http://www.hiendfi.com/phpBB2/

You have to send me your nickname (username), e mail and password to login on secret (unvisible to others) part of this forum (Forex part). This is for free

my e mail b.hajdinjak@hajdinjaklabs.com

Guys and girls........... come on !

I've been doing this for too long now to see the same ---- over and over again.

Trading is very personal - and there is a lot of money involved.

Trade what you see- and what you think is right,

Bonsoir messier et madame/medamoiselle

BH i think your misunderstanding what i was trying to say my friend. I didnt say give free advice trading signals etc. Post up what you are doing and why, like the majority of people do. There is no need to leave the forum and i would hate to think i had something to do with it.

All i was commenting on was the way you word things and your manorism towards criticism.

I know what its like when people dont listen to you after you gave them advice, then come crawling back afterwards, i have to deal with it everyday...

Look, at the end of the day feel free to do as you please. All i was offering was advice and my oppinion. If you dont want to listen to it fine, fair enough.

But remember one thing

"ANY info is better than NO info, even if the WRONG info"

If you do decide to leave, i wish you the best of luck in the future...

BH, your original post was leveled at Jamie Saettele by name. Given that he is an FXCM employee, professional trader, and respected member of this community, I felt that calling him names and declaring his analysis useless was beyond inappropriate. For traders not familiar with his success, I posted Jamie's trading record as a counter-balance to that view. I also suggested that you would attract more business being nice to your potential clients. The stark contrast with FXCM was my attempt to help you. That I did so inelegantly and with anger says more about me than you.

After I read your initial post, you obviously reconsidered and edited your post to remove Jamie's name. I did not notice this before I posted my responses. I respect you for doing that, but nonetheless feel obligated to explain why I was so angry.

Since your post as it now stands is not directed at any specific individual, I have no complaint.

====

There is more to the issue of disagreement that I think is worth pointing out. No trade occurs until there is agreement on price and a disagreement on value. A trader buys when he believes the price will rise; the trader selling to him only sells because he believes the price will fall. Based on sampling theory alone it is essential that people in the forum disagree with each other, or no trading will occur. It's not just about sharing ideas that are different, and having different opinions on the direction of the next move. There must be disagreement, or nobody gets paid. Simple as that.

It's also worth noting that any two -analysts- can each be right 70% of the time, and yet disagree with each other 60% of the time. A prediction success rate of 70% is high, and that fact that two such analysts would disagree most of the time is revealing. Two -traders-, each with a more typical 50% or less win/loss rate can disagree 100% of the time and both can still get paid consistently if there are enough other losing traders to pay them.

====

After setting the record in the US Trading Championship, Bob Prechter stopped trading, saying that is was just too hard to keep the money. Today he runs the largest and most successful market analysis firm in the world. When he is asked by people what to do to become a successful speculator, his first answer is simply: Don't. Very few will end the game a winner. Turn away now before you've lost all your money and it's too late.

====

Attached is my week 6 equity curve. I'm losing. I'm still up 350% on lower risk, but, I'm losing. While I could just continue to refill my account until I learn it (the nick 'hardknocklife' being an inside joke), nothing makes me angrier than giving my money to people I don't like. So, I'm taking Bob's advice. It is irrational for me to give away yet a 4th stake.

I sincerely appreciate the efforts by some here to help me. I will address you privately and individually.

Best of luck.

Originally Posted by JohnG_FX

Guys and girls........... come on !

I've been doing this for too long now to see the same ---- over and over again.

Trading is very personal - and there is a lot of money involved.

Trade what you see- and what you think is right,

Bonsoir messier et madame/medamoiselle

I agree with John here, seems to be a lot of bickering going on here.

"Take what you can and give nothing back"

Vince

Originally Posted by hardknocklife

BH, your original post was leveled at Jamie Saettele by name. Given that he is an FXCM employee, professional trader, and respected member of this community, I felt that calling him names and declaring his analysis useless was beyond inappropriate.

After I read your initial post, you obviously reconsidered and edited your post to remove Jamie's name. I did not notice this before I posted my responses. I respect you for doing that, but nonetheless feel obligated to explain why I was so angry.

.

All members from here can see that I almost always edit my first post because of language and because of better info. Yes I was wrote Jamiea Seatteles name but later I edit this in those who use EW strategy. So what? Can I write my opinion or not? Was I someone attack personally or only put discussion regard other technical info???

Who you are and what is your job here? Yes. My opinion is that Jamies EW analyses are useless and is dangereus to trade with!!! Have I right to post such opinion or not? If he is employee of FXCM this isn my problem. If he is employee of Microsoft this means I have something regard Bill??? And if he is member of this community this menas no ane can mention his name and put comments on his analyeses???
So my name is proper to mention here but his name NOT??? His EW analyses are out of discussion??
Are you serious?



They invitate us to discuss our ideas on this forum! So?!
Who you are really?? And what is your job here? Your reaction is totaly unsuitable and on every serious forum moderator would delete your post and warn you. But you looks like protector and defender here. Your reactions seems like that.

If this site have nothing with you, than please excuse me, but guilt is on site because of permittion such people like you to do what you do. Whay we have moderators here?

I thing, here will be much more really good people and really good traders IF this site would control such "supervisors" like you are here.


p.s. And one more (last) complain on this forum. If FXCM is owner of this site (this is new for me) than I am surprised how low tech software they use for this forum. From such name someone could expect FAR better technical support here.

Originally Posted by Vince

I agree with John here, seems to be a lot of bickering going on here.



Vince

Yes. But someone ask why???
To write what you want on forum (without affraid someone will attack on you because of this) is one of the civlization bassis in last 8000 years all ower the world (and is from old Babilon to today).

But here different rules have force?

Maybe only I have such feeling but it seems no one like good traders here.
So. This is my last post.

bye.

Originally Posted by BH-Eurofighter

Yes. But someone ask why???
To write what you want on forum (without affraid someone will attack on you because of this) is one of the civlization bassis in last 8000 years all ower the world (and is from old Babilon to today).

But here different rules have force.

Maybe only I have such feeling but it seems like no one want good traders here.

So. This is my last post.

bye.

Hi BH,

I would really hate to see you leave.
Hope the situation can be solved well.

Cheers.

i think from all commentaries including jamies its only supposed to be a guide and not the holy grail,yes sometimes he gets it wrong but also so do i.I value his commentary alot and from different people we can learn different things.
I used to read a guy on fxstreet called tony juste,i learned so much from his analysis even if he got it wrong a few times.We should be glad these people are even giving us free advice as im 1000 times a better trader in the past year from reading tony juste,rob booker jamie seattle blogs and of course i know my own style also.Tony juste no longer is on fxstreet and i really miss his commentaries it taught me about overbought/oversold scenarios and improved my tech analysis,then i learned so much about channels and supp /res from rob booker blog,and ill tell you so many times jamie seattle has been right on the money when i couldnt see it myself.
So there we go comeon guys we all are so lucky these people are here to help us for free and we should help each other also,no-one needs to quit this post just apologize and lets get on with trying to make some pips.

just asking,

i just finished see the latest rate closed at XE - The World's Favorite Currency and Foreign Exchange Site.

is that closed 24.00 hours? i seen there closed at 1.98809 but in several platform at 1.9913/19903..if the closed at 1.98809 that i am not done to attempt short when the market open tomorrow.i target wanna attempt short taht level..maybe tomorrow start opening market will fall like the stone..maybe retest 1.9830 then baounce back as sideways before resume the downtrend.just my opinion.

Originally Posted by lovelyforex

just asking,

i just finished see the latest rate closed at XE - The World's Favorite Currency and Foreign Exchange Site.

is that closed 24.00 hours? i seen there closed at 1.98809 but in several platform at 1.9913/19903..if the closed at 1.98809 that i am not done to attempt short when the market open tomorrow.i target wanna attempt short taht level..maybe tomorrow start opening market will fall like the stone..maybe retest 1.9830 then baounce back as sideways before resume the downtrend.just my opinion.

xe.com will show you the movement over the weekend but is no indication of direction on market open, most times the market will move back to close price and continue in the direction it was headed friday close, in this case UP not down. The short term move sunday into monday will be to the topside testing 2.0 and above once more. Do not get trapped looking to short this right now.